(no subject)
Aug. 19th, 2004 09:58 amOkay, this is something i've needed to get off my chest and into words, if only to be able to get to sleep at night instead of lying awake going over it in my head.
It also may explain why i'm so fixated on the asylum seeker issue in particular, and why this next election is so important.
Read it if you wish.
i used to be a very positive person.
i was always the glass-half-full optomist, and didn't tend to get down or stressed. Of course, i used to read and rant about the wrongs of the world, but rather than getting me down it used to be a case of "anger is an energy" and i'd use that as motivation for whatever political activity i'd be involved with (mostly Amnesty stuff).
Naturally, or naively, i assumed that if more people simply knew about some of the injustices and wrongs in the world, they'd be as angry as i was, and things would change. All that was needed was to let more people know. One such topic was the detention of asylum seekers, which i'd been involved in campaigns about with Amnesty for quite a while. Given the relatively open minded, 'fair go' attitude of most Australians, surely if they just knew the facts - that they weren't "illegal immigrants", hadn't broken any law and that there was no "flood" of boat people breaking on our shores - that would change. Given time and the fact that people were already becoming more aware, that's what i expected to happen.
Then, about three years ago, something changed.
A ship called the MV Tampa rescued several hundred asylum seekers from a sinking boat and tried to land at a port in Australian territory. The Australian government was so horrified at the prospect these people might even be allowed to ask for asylum that it sent armed SAS troops to stop them. And, as various countries denied any responsibility to deal with these people, as if they were some sort of human garbage that nobody wanted to touch, i just kept picturing the story of that boatload of Jewish refugees who were refused entry to port after port in the '30s and ended up having to sail back to Europe and into the hands of the Nazis.
But that wasn't the worst of it. Rather than facing a huge outcry, the Howard government's popularity suddenly soared, after hitting an all time low in the wake of the GST, and the ALP couldn't fall over itself fast enough to jump on the bandwagon and claim it would have done the same thing only better. Here was possibly the most apalling and cold-hearted act of indecency i could remember my country committing, and the Australian people were roaring with approval, which they confirmed by rewarding Howard with another term. My opinion of my fellow Australians plummeted to a new low.
The timing was great, too. This incident had come just after a dinner with some relatives, where i had discovered just how racist some of their views were and been gobsmacked at how i could have known someone for ten years without realising they thought that way. That had been where i'd first heard mention of the Tampa, as "another boatload of them on their way here" and an example of "the shit we're letting into the country". At the time i'd been amazed to even know anyone who actually thought that way, but now it seemed that was the flavour of popular opinion.
Then, in the middle of all this, some religious nutjobs crashed airliners full of terrified passengers into buildings to murder thousands of other terrified civilians, shocking the world to a standstill. All of a sudden the world was turned upside down, and despite what gripes anyone had against the US, it paled in the face of the slaughter of so many innocent people and knowing that this carnage was down to religious extremists who would happily butcher any of us just for being different to themselves. Then the US came back with it's "with us or against us" rhetoric and the War on Terror, and all of a sudden the world was in a war to the death and we had to choose which set of bad guys we were on the side of. Then, as we geared up for war, first with the Taleban and later with Iraq, we were still locking people up for running away from those same regimes.
If the Tampa had been what floored my opinion of people, this really sunk the boot in. As one of those family members described watching Arab taxi drivers at the airport cheering at the news of the World Trade Centre death toll, i had no argument to come back with. Now it wasn't just Australians i was disillusioned with, it was the whole human race.
For the past couple of years, there's been something changed in me. My personal life has for the most part been pretty good, but underneath it all something is different, a pessimism and cynicism that's hung around like a black cloud. When i stop and think about it, i can see one possible root cause of what's different - i don't like people any more. That is to say, i like people as individuals, and can still see the warmth and humanity in most people i encounter, but as a group, as a herd, they suck. There are still things which inspire me and remind me that humans aren't all bad, but much as i'd like to i can't escape the feeling that that's the exception, that for the most part the human race is petty and selfish and hateful. i try to stay positive, but it's hard when every other news story i see seems to reinforce the feeling that the human race would be better exterminated as soon as a humane method is found.
And it all started with the Tampa. It took me a while to pinpoint it there, but i realise now that that was the time when i lost my faith in the people around me. Even though i told myself it was just because people had been misled, that they'd been fed for too long on lies about 'illegal immigrants' and nonexistant hordes of boat people, and newer lies about 'children overboard', but deep down i couldn't escape the basic suspicion that people swallowed all this crap mainly because they wanted to, because it made them feel better about simply not wanting those towel-headed nig-nogs moving in next door to them, or that they mightn't have as much luxury to gorge themselves on if they let anyone else in to share a piece of the pie.
That's why this asylum seeker business is such a touchy subject for me, and why i'm so anxious about how this next election is going to go. Not because we've got a government that's so unrepresentative of the Australian character, but because i'm afraid that it does represent it. And this election will be the test of that. Because there's no benefit of the doubt or question of being misled this time - everyone knows that they lied, about the 'children overboard' and so much else, and if all that's forgiven and the majority of Australian people still want Howard as our leader, then it's not because they have been misled, it's because he's told them what they want to hear, because, at the bottom of it all, the Australian character really is "screw you, mate, i'm all right".
And that could well be the last straw.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 12:53 am (UTC)But I too am an optomist and I know that the darkest hour is just before dawn.
Perhaps we have reached our darkest hour.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 12:57 am (UTC)i'll drink to that.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 02:11 am (UTC)I too am resigned to thinking most peoples attitude really is "screw you mate, I'm alright" - the whole "we have it good, why should anyone else have what I have? Stuff them!" thing. Grrr.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 03:41 am (UTC)You know what, i'm fed up with feeling like this.
i knew there was a reason i had to get this off my chest, and i've decided it's so i could work through it and come to a conclusion - that i bloody well want to get my positivity back. i think i need to work on that for myself, as a big goal (maybe we all do).
Of course, getting rid of Howard will help that, so i want to find any way i can help to make that happen.
Plus, then i won't have to fight the urge to "go all Lee Harvey Oswald on somebody's ass". ;)
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 02:18 am (UTC)I can be a racist bitch at times myself (Fran can vow to this) - but that is when my emotional/irrational side is in control.
Now that I am getting older & not so blinded by the beliefs of my family - I can see that if the shoe was on the other foot (which is has & can be, seeing I come from an Islander family) I SHOULD be able to relate to this situation.
My faith in humanity died quite some time ago - in my 20's when I realised no one DOES give a shit unless it effects them directly.
I pray to a God that does not exist that this election people try & see "the shoe on the other foot".
Otherwise - being the pessimist I am - I can forsee the end of this wonderful country & possibly the end of the world. Well maybe not the END as such - but the degradation of our living standards & our ethics.
I always enjoy your posts Darryn. It is a relief that there ARE thinking people out there - not just sheep following the leader.
Take care mate
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 03:08 am (UTC)i really hope Fran's right and this is just the dark hour before the dawn.
People *can* give a shit if they want to. Even my 'racist relos' are really good people, always willing to put themselves out for their friends and loved ones (way more than i do), which is why it surprised me to hear what came out of their mouths. They just seem to have this notion of a line in the sand beyond which giving a shit ends. If only people would get the fuck over this idea of looking out for their own and to hell with everybody else.
When i'm less cynical, that's what i'm hoping for - that people can remember to give a shit like i know they're capable of. Maybe this is just a phase, and things are going to start to turn back around soon. (And i'd love to ba able to get back to my old self too).
A good start would be getting rid of those evil bastards who are suiting their own ends by encouraging people to be as petty and mean-spirited as they can.
Bring it on.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 04:26 am (UTC)I am with you mate - and I wish I could be as optimistic as Fran bubble. Maybe I am slighty tainted by my past experiences - as when I REALLY needed someone in my youth - NO ONE came to my help. I just wish every cunt wasnt in it just for themselves & thought of the greater picture.
If this gives you any hope. I gave my tram seat up to an Elderly Gentleman today. He told me "That was a very considerate thing to do. Thank you love." And EVERYONE on the tram looked at me in surprise - especially when I called him Sir. Is courtesy that fucked these days, that something as simple as having respect for your elders comes as such a shock?
THAT made me feel so good & if EVERYONE could do just little actions like this to help/assist others I am sure we COULD change the world.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 05:07 am (UTC)You're right. If everyone made that bit effort, the world would be so much better a place to live in.
Good on you. Hope it's contagious.
Thanks mate - just my little bit of goodness in the world
Date: 2004-08-19 05:21 am (UTC)Like I say- "Thanks" to EVERY SINGLE Tram driver that I get off at. Nothing like a bit of common courtesy. heh or maybe its the Queenslander in me - HEY MATE!
Re: Thanks mate - just my little bit of goodness in the world
Date: 2004-08-19 05:34 am (UTC)Hey, i do that too. (Not every time, but every time i remember to).
i have a feeling the reason most people don't do stuff like that is because they're so fricking miserable and caught up in things, but like you said, doing something nice does make you feel better so they should give it a try.
i think there's a lot to be said for setting an example by the way you live your life. Thanks for reminding me (and i'll remember that next time the world tries to make me feel guilty for *not* being an arsehole).
Re: Thanks mate - just my little bit of goodness in the world
Date: 2004-08-19 06:27 am (UTC)Take care mate & dont be so hard on yourself.
For you too even write this post means that you care.
Example is the only thing we can do. And when there are grommits & others that are lead by example - we need to have SOME good ones there to outweigh the bad examples.
:)
I have to meet you one day mate - I love to talk to people with BRAINS!!!
Re: Thanks mate - just my little bit of goodness in the world
Date: 2004-08-19 06:44 am (UTC)i'm sure we shall meet up sooner or later. (May even be sober enough to remember the conversation this time).
:)
Re: Thanks mate - just my little bit of goodness in the world
Date: 2004-08-19 06:46 am (UTC)~~hangs head in shame~~
Its all Jacks fault you know. ;)
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 02:47 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 03:33 am (UTC)Thinking about it, i can see two immediate priorities that need to be sorted before getting back to work on fixing what's fucked up in the world. One is to get rid of this particular gang of villains before they do any more damage (both to the world and people's minds) and the other is to try to rebuild my own faith in people in general (one may help the other, but i'm not game to count on it).
Even if i don't get back to the same starry-eyed optomism i had before, i at least want to believe there's more to like in humanity than to hate. It's probably worth making a conscious effort to seek out what's good and decent in humanity, instead of dwelling on the awful shit we do to each other - that doesn't get me fired up any more, it just makes me depressed.
Time for a new approach.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-21 10:34 am (UTC)Apparently recent polls look promising as far as getting rid of the worlds' maniac leaders is concerned (and also, in amusing news,
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 03:30 am (UTC)I want now to leave australia, because as I often say 'this is not *my* Australia' and I'm damned if I'll languish here only to see us degenerate into a bunch of difference hating John laws/Stan Zemanack clones, and be fucked over royally by the government, who can smile whilst letting someone die.
Most people dont realise that *it is not illegal to seek asylum in australia* and that *we take less refugees than almost any other first world country* - a fact that I have to repeat over and over again.
It's just not fair and that's the bit that really gets me. Our government does not have even an ounce of compassion, even in the face of death and suffering. Some John Howard cronie was trying to defend him about his blatant fucking lies on Lateline last night and it was a shocking display. They simply will not admit to ANYTHING.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 04:21 am (UTC)(LJ seems to have eaten my last reply. Oh well).
Anyway, despite what so many people i know are saying, leaving Australia won't really solve anything. Sure, we could go somewhere like Canada or New Zealand, but Australians aren't so different to Canadians or New Zealanders so if it can happen here it can happen there. The whole world seems to be sliding into the Dark Ages, so i figure here is as good a place as any to stand and fight it. (And yes, that's the same speech i gave myself last time Howard got in).
Fuck it. This is my home and the last people i want to surrender it to are the likes of Howard, Bolt and Zemaneck.
i've had enough of this moping, i'm ready for war.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 05:17 am (UTC)I'm past feeling like that sadly - it seems every time we protest (like the record protest turnouts against going to war, and for refugees, and for saying sorry to the aboriginal people for past wrongs) it's been so totally futile that I feel there is nothing I or anyone else can do, even if we mobilise anti-Howard army.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:28 am (UTC)Street protests really became obsolete in the '70s, with the possible exception of huge turnouts on the scale of the S11 or Iraq war protests. Otherwise it's just an exercise in associating the 'cause' in question with an unwashed hippy rent-a-crowd image and alienating the exact people who are voting for the Libs and need to be gotten through to.
Mind you, if Howard gets in again, i'm up for a riot.
Seriously.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-21 10:40 am (UTC)For me tha main use of protests and marches is to keep the flame burning, and a sense of community and solidarity among those who do care. The World Environment Day march was a case in point. It gave me a lot of the motivation I'd really been lacking, and a sense that there were other people here who were going to join my voice in the other forms of activism that might make politicians sit up and take even a little notice. Activism sometimes is just for activists, but that's fine. Because sometimes, we need it.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-23 03:06 am (UTC)They can work, but i think they need to be used carefully and sparingly. It's quite depressing to watch the ever-dwindling turnout to rally after rally on the Asylum Seeker issue - i'm torn between thinking it's probably reached the point of being counter-productive yet at the same time feeling obliged to turn up to stop it being even more counter-productive. Thing is, they're really only useful as a statement of mass opinion, so you need to be able to muster a decent crowd to not look silly.
There was an interesting article in the last Big Issue about the anti-war protests. It suggested that, since so many protested yet the government ignored it and went to war anyway, what we really should be protesting for is a change to the law so that the government *can't* go to war against the public's wishes. Interesting idea, though it still would leave the manipulation of public opinion unaddressed.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-23 01:30 pm (UTC)That's a really good point about that law, though. If it ever went through, oh boy...
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 05:28 am (UTC)I was spending my days at work going through every talkback call, attributing tone to each of the callers' viewpoints. Never before had I realised the capacity of the general population for hatred and bigotry. I knew that the Howard government had many supporters, however I wasn't expecting so many people to suggest bombing the Tampa, so that the refugees would die and there'd be no more trouble from them. Every day, hundreds of people called talkback radio about this issue. Only a small proportion of them discussed the refugees as if they were human beings. Many were angered by the term 'asylum seekers', arguing that they were 'illegal aliens'.
I remember discussing this with a couple of good friends at Abyss, and was horrified when both of them said that the line had to be drawn and we couldn't just let anybody in and the government shouldn't allow the people on the Tampa to seek asylum. I was horrified.
I don't think I've ever recovered from that.
One memory that heartens me, though, is of being part of the largest crowd I have ever seen, gathered just before the bombing of Iraq, saying 'no'. Howard didn't listen, but being part of that group, then seeing footage of huge protests around the world, helped to restore a little faith.
Hang in there.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 05:38 am (UTC)think non-homicidal thoughts..
think non-homicidal thoughts..
think non-homicidal thoughts..
think non-homicidal thoughts..
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:00 am (UTC)I was getting so involved in the catharsis of that reply that I wasn't exactly considerate of your feelings. Also being exposed to so much of that type of sentiment tends to make you forget that not everyone hears how dreadful talkback radio is.
I'm glad I didn't elaborate any further ...
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:22 am (UTC)'sokay.
i barely count talkback radio callers as homo sapiens, let alone representative of the views of the nation.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:28 am (UTC)I just remembered a more uplifting anecdote from about that time - I had been working quite late, so I got a taxi home. The taxi driver saw the company name above the building as I was coming out, and asked if it was really true that 90-something per cent of people were against refugees (I can't remember the exact issue she was referring to - this was the time of Tampa, Woomera Detention Centre, border excision etc), because she didn't believe it, and many people who travelled in her taxi didn't either. It was nice to be able to put talkback callers back into their very insignificant, albeit prominent, place in the real world.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:26 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:42 am (UTC)i've had a gutful of feeling that way.
Now i'm going back to focussing on what we *could* be.
It's time to take up the mission to bring compassion, goodwill and enlightenment to the masses, even if i have to ram it violently into their stupid thick skulls.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:32 am (UTC)Sad, really, isn't it?
What had me in a rage one or two nights ago was channel-flicking and finding Little Johnny being handed soft questions by Ray Martin. It came down to this [paraphrasing]...
Ray: "So, 75% of the Australian public think you lied to them."
Johnny: "But 25% think I'm honest!" Then, he went on to quote stats from the same survey, where approx one third of those who knew Howard had lied would vote for him anyway.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 06:47 am (UTC)Ray Martin.
ugh.
i dread the day he runs for parliament.
no subject
Date: 2004-08-19 09:25 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-08-20 05:00 am (UTC)I do not believe that human nature is intrinsically malicious. Most anyone you actually talk to, you can find some common ground . . . The problem being, to create that time to really communicate with them.
Our developing paradigm-of-communication is one that tends to divide and isolate individuals (and I suppose groups), to suppress naturally emergent opinion and to destroy community. (Part of what I call "arachnitecture"). Part of that is the "revolution-of-lowered-expectations". People consider first what they might have to lose in any situation, rather than what they might have to gain (unless, of course the "gain" is visibly at the expense of another, in which case such gain is perceived as real, to some fraction of that perceived loss).
And it's a lot less effort to be negative and condemnatory that it is to be positive and permissive. These days it's hard to be relaxed and happy, and you normally need to be relaxed and happy to think straight. Like in "Bowling For Columbine" - control through fear. That's how all the Big Lies get perpetrated.
So how do you fix the problem? Well, you'd have to re-create the idea of community, somehow . . . and you can't really force an emergent process. Why is it that we don't talk to our neighbours? Was it always that way? It's only here, in the Westworld, that, if you get on a tram, you go and sit as far away as possible from anyone else on the vehicle . . . to be isolate is "polite". This is a constructed behaviour.
Hmm . . . lots more complaint from me, but I find myself short of creative suggestions. Question: is the re-creation of "community" through, say, the Internet, possible? what would need to be done? 'Cos a "Community" is NOT the same thing as an "Organisation" . . . and without {wrapping oneself} in the {hijackable} {dead hand/straitjacket) of an {Org}, it seems impossible to make any kind of difference.
Jay Superfluous
[Music for Refugee Issue: T. V. Smith - "Walk The Plank"]
no subject
Date: 2004-08-20 05:34 am (UTC)i think the best place to start, as gothsuck said, is by how you live your life. i'm just remembering now hearing somewhere the idea of 'living life as if the world was the way it should be', which i think i'm only just starting to understand. Connecting with people and acting in a way to help them be more 'relaxed and happy' would have to have flow-on benefits.
(Hey - this is all the Tree Hugging Hippy Shit i used to believe and preach but lost faith in. Maybe there's hope yet).
The internet is good for communication like this, as well as dealing with being 'lost' in a huge city or world. But i guess we have to be careful not to let it cut us off from other people around us.